Being let go for “performance” leaves many California workers assuming the conversation is over. Yet the company is offering money, which means it wants something in return. That something is usually your promise not to bring legal claims, and what that promise is worth depends on what happened before you were fired.
Questions and answers
Can I negotiate severance if I was fired for performance?
Yes. A severance offer is a trade, and a performance label doesn’t take away your ability to counter it. The company is paying for a release of your claims, so the offer is worth discussing whatever reason was written on your termination notice.
What is the company getting when I sign?
Most severance agreements include a general release, a promise not to sue over your job or your exit. California’s Civil Rights Department says an employer may include one in a separation agreement, as long as the release is otherwise lawful and valid (Gov. Code § 12964.5(b)). If you have no claims, that promise has little value. If you have even one credible claim, it is worth more.
Can “performance” be a cover for something else?
It can. Some patterns to look for are reviews that were fine until you complained about pay, safety, or a manager, or until you asked for leave or an accommodation. Others are a paper trail that only appeared recently, or coworkers with similar issues who kept their jobs. None of that proves a case, but it is what a company weighs when it decides how much to offer.
How much time do I have to decide?
An employer offering a separation agreement must tell you that you can consult an attorney and give you at least five business days to do so, and it can’t require you to sign the day it’s offered (Gov. Code § 12964.5(b)). Workers who are 40 or older may get more time under federal law. Claim deadlines run separately, so a deadline on the offer shouldn’t push you into signing before you know what you’d be giving up.
Do I still get my final paycheck and unemployment?
Your final pay is owed no matter what you sign, including accrued vacation, and it is due immediately when you are discharged (Lab. Code §§ 201, 227.3). On unemployment, EDD says that not every employee fired for unsatisfactory performance was fired for misconduct, and inefficient performance is ordinarily not misconduct (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 22, § 1256-38). EDD makes its own decision either way.
What should I do before I sign?
Request your personnel file in writing, since the employer has 30 calendar days to respond (Lab. Code § 1198.5). Write down a timeline of your reviews, warnings, complaints, and leave requests. Then look past the dollar figure to health coverage, a neutral reference, how your exit is described, and any bonuses or commissions.
Read the full guide on Severance.law: Can I Negotiate Severance If I Was Fired for Performance?