A New Jersey treatment center laid off two union organizers, then offered them severance agreements. On Oct. 21, a federal labor judge ruled that the layoffs were illegal and that the severance agreement was illegal too. It raises important questions about your rights if you are holding a severance offer.
Questions and answers
Can a severance agreement ban me from saying anything negative about my employer?
Sometimes, but not always. In the Alina Lodge case, the agreement said the employee “agrees not to … disparage Employer, nor any individuals, products or services affiliated with Employer.” The National Labor Relations Board judge wrote that this clause “broadly bans employees from disparaging Alina.” The judge found the agreement illegal. A judge’s ruling is a recommendation, and the case was transferred to the Board, so the employer can appeal.
What did the 2023 NLRB decision change?
In McLaren Macomb, the Board held that simply offering a severance agreement that broadly makes workers give up their rights under the National Labor Relations Act is illegal, whether or not anyone signs. Those rights include talking with co-workers and the public about pay and working conditions.
Is that rule safe from being overturned?
No. It is still the law as of the date of the source story, but the Board’s general counsel has asked the Board to overrule it. The Board’s Republican majority, in place since August, has not done so yet. Check the current status before you rely on it.
Does the rule protect every worker?
No. The National Labor Relations Act excludes supervisors, independent contractors, and government workers. If you managed people with real authority to hire, fire, or discipline, this rule probably does not cover you.
What protections stay in place no matter what the Board does?
The EEOC says provisions that try to stop you from filing a discrimination charge are unenforceable. Workers 40 and older who are asked to waive age discrimination claims get at least 21 days to consider the offer (45 in a group layoff) and 7 days to revoke after signing. The federal Speak Out Act makes certain nondisclosure and non-disparagement clauses signed before a sexual harassment or assault dispute arose unenforceable in court for that dispute.
Read the full story on WorkersRights.News: A judge struck down a severance gag clause. Check yours before you sign.